by jrhees » Thu May 20, 2004 8:52 pm
Usually the problem with repeaters is that they create a *lot* of background IR noise. Here's why:
A repeater is not 'smart' -- i.e., it does not actually decode nor generate IR codes. Instead, it simply acts like an infrared 'microphone/speaker' combo. So, *any* IR energy it sees in one room it blasts in the other. There's a *lot* or IR noise floating around, from the Sun, heat sources, lights, etc. etc.
A good analogy is to think of putting a microphone in one room and the amplifier/speaker in another. Then, turning the volume way up. Sure, you'll hear someone talking in the other room fine, but you'll also amplify the air conditioner, and any other noises in the room.
IR Repeaters usually work fine despite this problem, since the equipment being controlled knows exactly what IR code and format to look for. So, even though your TV's IR reveiver sees a lot of IR 'noise', it also knows when the 'right' IR codes are coming in.
The USB-UIRT, on the other hand, does not have this advantage. While it *can* make an educated guess on what is an IR code and what is simply noise, it *cannot* be nearly as selective since it is universal and needs to see all sorts of remote brands and protocols. Therein lines the reason why you see all sorts of codes being generated when the IR repeater is in use.
Hope this helps to clarify things...
-Jon